Sunday, October 2, 2016
Stasis Theory in "Rights of Animals" by Brigid Brophy
The Stasis Theory in "The Rights of Animals" by Brigid Brophy is that animals need to be treated as fellow human beings. Brophy argues that if it wrong with humans, then it should be wrong with animals as well. After all, why should they be treated differently? People's acceptance towards this behavior has led this to happen. However, changing our perspective on animal welfare will lead to everlasting changes. She predicts it will be ridiculous, she that animal cruelty existed, like slavery existed. She doesn't directly address who should handle the issue, but appeals to the reader to understand that it is just as bad to torture an animal as it is to a human. She insists we don't have the right to decide what happens another being, and it is extremely wrong that we end their lives. Animal welfare is a community everyone should feel obligated to join.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I am interested to know what she, or even what in the 60s, was considered harmful treatment. I know that some believe any form of animal testing is cruelty. Was that ideal built over time or arose in the 60s? While Brophy clearly establishes the morality of the issue I think the importance of what is to be done needs to be in the stasis to be a strong argument.
ReplyDeleteI am interested to know what she, or even what in the 60s, was considered harmful treatment. I know that some believe any form of animal testing is cruelty. Was that ideal built over time or arose in the 60s? While Brophy clearly establishes the morality of the issue I think the importance of what is to be done needs to be in the stasis to be a strong argument.
ReplyDeleteIt seems to me that Brophy's argument is not very clear. It looks like it is driven by more subjective reasons than objective reasons. I guess one's beliefs on animal cruelty and where to draw the lines are subjective but as an author, Brophy should be more explicit. Connecting her argument to modern times, animal cruelty is still a popular taboo issue. Although it is not breaking news, people do advocate against it strongly. Many people choose to become vegan or vegetarian and choose to use cruelty-free makeup products.
ReplyDelete